Quoted from pickleric:That's the challenge. Many are tired of Movie, Band, and Comic themes… but what else do we have with mass appeal than those things? BBQ isn’t it.
The best rumored themes at the moment
Matrix
5th Element
Themes I’d like, but many won’t like
Daft Punk
Hackers (The Movie)
What themes would you like to see?
I like most of those ideas. I think Hackers is more in the homebrew territory if anything. The thing about it, and the number one thing that really gets under my skin when it comes to themes, is that people can't let go of their biases. If you like something, people automatically think its a good theme. If you don't, then its automatically a bad theme. Like for example, I HATE Harry Potter with a dying passion. HP fans make me cringe like nothing else. But I know that game could be huge. HOWEVER, it could also be so "huge" that it blows up in peoples faces. Expectations are so high, that no game could ever live up to them. Do you make the wizarding world of harry potter pin and risk another TS4 scenario? I don't know.
Daft Punk could be really good, I love the idea from a personal standpoint, but thats like maybe a P3 theme. If there ever was an EDM "band" game to be made, I think Daft Punk is the easy choice. I'd put it in like the soft maybe category.
People always say they are sick of rock band games, but they still continue to be sales hits. Its just like people who say they want original themes and they keep flopping. I have heard Journey tossed around a lot as a rumor, and I love Journey, but I think its a bad idea. I think Motley Crue is probably the most obvious choice if a company wanted to make a hit band game, that or Van Halen. Both bands I consider to be good from my subjective viewpoint but are far from my favorites, but I see them from an objective viewpoint as being good sellers/good bands to have a game based on.
Comic games do seem to be falling out of favor, but we've also had a series of lower tier comic titles. I'm interested to see if Elwin's X-men 97 can buck that trend, I think it will do fairly well. I think another Spiderman game could also do well. If somebody gets some DC rights a Batman game would also be a good choice. Or do a game based on Batman the movie from 1989. That was rumored from Dutch for a while, so who knows. I know theres already fairly recent Batman, xmen, and spiderman games out there, but I think the market will accept more.
Other themes I could see doing well:
Bloodsport
Robocop
Rambo
Magic the Gathering (could be a generic swords and sorcery type game even with the MTG tie in, AP maybe?)
Total Recall
Beverly Hills Cop (particularly interesting with the new one about to drop)
Needs a few more years before its nostalgic enough for the pinball demo but
Adventure Time
Invader Zim
I don't know I'm sure I could come up with plenty more but those are a few I can rattle off the top of my head. Theres other obvious ones too like Die Hard but I just don't think they'd have a chance of getting Bruce Willis' likeness.