Nowhere near as good as TFTC. I think it's a great game to look at and the transporter is cool. It's fun to go over the playfield and pick out characters from classic episodes. There are no Kirk or Spock call outs and after awhile, with limited space, the gameplay just wasn't where it needed to be for us to keep it. As a Star Trek fan, I do think it's fun, and if I had more room I would have kept it, FWIW.