Play them all.
A lot.
Then make your choice.
If you really want to know what others think... Consider checking out reviews and collections. Once the personality of the reviewer comes through (their collection), the reviews make all the more sense. I usually look at the collections of the reviewers and if I think to myself "I like that person's collection." I consider their reviews more carefully.
My pin-philosophy is: "If the game has game, I want to play it!"