Quoted from Yoko2una:

As TMNT was my first NIB purchase and I had some of the same issues, allow me to share some thoughts...
1) Loose Coin Box - Same in my game. I ended up finding that the left sling flasher was disconnected as a result and had to bend some things back together for it to plug back in.
2) PF Print Quality - I'm in the same boat. I complained to my distro in October and was promised a new PF. I actually made my concerns about poor PF's known before I made the purchase and his assurance to me was that "Stern solved all the PF issues". So I bought, of course got a shit grainy PF, and showed him pics. I was promised a new Pro PF "when Stern reruns TMNT Pro". In April, I sent a 6mo follow up letter asking the status and it's been crickets since.
I'm at the point where I'm ready to reveal the entire conversation from the Distro. He's supposed to be "one of the good guys" in the hobby, but I'm yet to get the service I expected.
If you can return the game, I'd do so on the rust alone. Probably wasn't stored well and could have other issues you can't see.