The games from my childhood that I now own are both video arcade games: Berzerk and Time Traveler. The only pins I played as a kid (that I can remember) were Funhouse and Dr. Dude, but I don't really have any desire to own either of them.
I didn't really get into pins until about ten years ago. CFTBL, TAF, IJ, and MB were the ones that grabbed me. I've owned the first two, and now own a MB. My best friend owned an IJ, so I got my fix on that one.