Hi Bitbyte..
Solar City is a great game.. ive just overhauled mine and got her running nice and smoothly..
First of all the TILT light in the backbox WILL be illuminated when you first turn the game on.. this is normal. But.... once the game goes into reset this should go off.
The suggestion earlier to set the 1st player ( just work with Player 1 and get the game running.. then we can go to multiplayer issues if any) scores to anything but zero... take out the reels and manually click them over. Turn game off and on again and with credits ( how did you set free play by the way?) press the start button.. TILT should go off and score reels start to turn and set to Zero.. if this doesnt happen then you need to address the issue in the head with the score reels before attempting anything else... if ANY one of the reels does not register its ZERO point then motor wil turn continuously searching for this state.