To me, BSD. Wanted to like Shadow because of the top B list attention it gets but even in my large collection it didn't stick. I listed a bunch of games for "I'll let it go for this much" money and of course the one I didn't want to leave, BSD, is the only one that sold. Got 3500 for it but it was sweet. I miss it already. It's so much fun, quick, great call outs for fans of the movie which I am, and it's unforgiving in a good way meaning that you can go from a quick drain to an awesome ball that exposes just about every element of the game. If my collection was up to 30 Shadow would be in but that isn't happening since I have to downsize now anyway, hence the sale of BSD.