I prefer Creature. It's just a fun game and not a complete butt kicker like BSD. I also agree BSD is getting overrated. It's a great game but not much variety in gameplay. You just try to hit the same shots over and over to try and get the mb's going at the same time. Fun when it happens but very tough to do. So you either have a really good game or a miserable one. Lightning flippers make it tough but the real frustrating thing is all the drains you get from the ball just coming out of the top area of the playfield. Creature has a lot of fun modes and more shots. I think the theme is much better since not really a fan of horror stuff.