I think part of the problem is while Chris can be pretty toxic (seems less toxic than he used to be, or maybe that's a factor of him going behind a paywall), he can really whip a few of his fans into some misguided frenzies. I believe I heard some fans might have been doing some doxxing of "enemies" which is a frightening thing to be on the other end of.
I don't think they should have cancelled the award. I don't think it was right to try to erase the history of all his wins. If they wanted to say he was no longer eligible, that's their prerogative. But maybe they could have worked something out, like letting Chris present the award to others or just giving him an achievement award. Although knowing Chris, he'd probably still find something to get worked up over. But the point is there was a better way to go about this.
And while I personally feel nothing of value is lost, I think we should recognize that a wide variety of podcasters put a lot of time and effort into their content. The number of votes they got meant something to them. Chris clearly wants the validation, and maybe he feels a little bit less guilty about some of the uglier things he says (like calling for employees to be fired). Without these awards, I hope more people send in a small tip to their favorite podcasts or order some of their merchandise to show support for the hundreds, if not thousands, of hours of work they put into giving content to the community.