Thanks for all the suggestions, I really appreciate them.
So the flipper does not fire up when turned on, only when game starts or in the tests menu. In the flipper coil tests, left flipper power and hold both work as expected (meaning they come back down after firing)
In the switch tests, the left flipper button is stuck in closed which would explain the behavior but not sure why it’s stuck that way, the PCB is recognizing the button presses with an additional green led when pressed (pictured below)
446D7100-0353-4FB5-B6E9-BE26C3AE0520 (resized).jpeg958323F4-6355-408F-A3AE-D37D99DC6E9E (resized).jpeg
Also, the switch test itself shows the press in the menu, via the small square in the lower right corner of the matrix (also pictured before/during press).
696532C9-DB2F-4EFD-A8ED-4093BF1FE19B (resized).jpeg283C59C4-5203-4CF3-AECE-EE1063EAC864 (resized).jpeg
EOS switch test is working as expected too.
Based on the suggestion above, the opto board, on the right flipper, looks like nothing is stuck or not clearing, last pictures before/during right flipper press.
68DB79B1-BDA2-4A9E-8AF2-082A959E58EA.jpeg49C6B046-9257-49D5-8D6F-6442877931AF.jpeg
Based on this info, does it lead more to transistor? No fuses blown, confirmed