Replay Amusement Museum

Nice establishment and a great selection of games in generally good repair, but expect a couple to be down for maintenance. $13 general admission for the day. This place would be perfect if they served beverages. However, they will let you leave and comeback the same day; lots of restaurants are nearly to refuel you between games!

60 games, but only the new titles are clean, most are in desperate need of a playfield cleaning or other maintenance. 9 were OoO and seven others had issues from flippers and pop bumpers not working to displays needing replacement... some had completely roaches playfields. Still enough to have fun, but expected higher standard of maintenance... kinda sad to see this much neglect in one collection.


119 E Tarpon Ave, Tarpon Springs, FL 34689, USA

Get directions View on Pinside Map

Location is indicated on the map by the icon.

Added by

2014-09-21 03:28:41

Last edited by

2020-02-23 02:30:48

Games list

Last updated on 2020-02-23 02:30:48

The following games are listed for this location.

Stern, 2012 - Added on 2017-11-08

Bally, 1992 - Added on 2019-01-13

Stern, 2017 - Added on 2019-01-13

Williams, 1976 - Added on 2017-11-08

Data East, 1991 - Added on 2017-02-09

Stern, 2019 - Added on 2020-01-16

Segasa-Sonic, 1977

Stern, 2018 - Added on 2019-01-13

Gottlieb, 1975 - Added on 2017-11-08

Stern Electronics, 1980 - Added on 2017-11-08

Williams, 1990

Stern, 2017 - Added on 2019-01-13

Stern, 2018 - Added on 2020-01-16

Stern, 2010 - Added on 2017-02-09

Gottlieb, 1977 - Added on 2017-11-08

Chicago Gaming Co., 2018 - Added on 2020-01-16

Bally, 1997 - Added on 2017-02-09

Stern Electronics, 1982

Williams, 1994 - Added on 2017-11-08

Stern, 2017 - Added on 2017-11-08

Stern, 2019 - Added on 2020-01-16

Williams, 1970 - Added on 2017-11-08

Gottlieb, 1976

Williams, 1988

Williams, 1991 - Added on 2017-02-09

Data East, 1994 - Added on 2017-11-08

Williams, 1993

Jersey Jack, 2013

Bally, 1980


Visit this location without having to travel!

20150729_154856 (Custom).jpg


5 years ago

Killer lineup! Big selection all the way from early EMs to Jersey Jack's Wizard of Oz.

Most machines were in good shape. TSPP was barely playable though - lots of GI bulbs out and the garage door was barely functional.

5 years ago

Called their number during advertised business hours and got a recording. Not comforting. I'd like to talk with a real person in real time about holiday hours.

5 years ago

I entered the previous comment a bit too soon. I sent a message to Replay through their website. I had a response from Bryan within an hour confirming they were open. I made the drive out and had a blast! A few games were down for maintenance and some were dirty, but an overall great experience. There's a Seeburg G jukebox, but it wasn't working.

7 months ago

Made the 3 hour drive from Fort Myers to Tarpon Springs specifically to hit this place. Not disappointed! Cool vibe and a lot of great tables. Played for four hours (most of that on a Bloodsuckers Rick & Morty). Very little Jersey Jack represented, and TSPP wasn't 100% functional, but for $14 I have nothing to complain about. Several machines being actively worked on and a great vibe from the staff made it a great trip. I'll be back!

Add a comment

Wanna make a comment? Click here to sign in or register.

More locations!

Check out the interactive Pinball map, containing thousands of (public) locations where you can get your silverball fix!

Add a location!

Do you know a location with pinball machines, which isn't on our pinball map yet? Add it to our database!

Hey there! Got a moment?

Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run thanks to donations from our visitors? Please donate to Pinside, support the site and get anext to your username to show for it! Donate to Pinside