Stern
Pirates of the Caribbean Pinside Rating
This game received 534 approved Pinsider ratings and currently rates 7.958 /10
Pirates of the Caribbean
Score breakdown
Score breakdown in the 4 main categories:
Game Design: 8.098
Artwork: 7.777
Sounds/Music: 7.435
Other Aspects: 8.074
Pinside staff rating
This is how we, the very knowledgeable (wink wink) Pinside.com staff & moderators rate this game. 8 of us have rated this game.
Found 309 ratings (with comment) on this game
There are 309 ratings (that include a comment) on this game.
Currently showing results page 8 of 13.
List options
Fenton
Galena, IL
6.968/10
10 years ago
This game has a great theme. Everyone loves Pirates of the Carribean and Johnny Depp.
It's a lot of fun and has a number of cool features. I love the ship sinking into the playfield, if only because the kids love it, and that's what makes any game fun. I generally dislike Stern games because of the junk toys littering the playfield, but this one looks nice.
The game is smoot to play and the rules are quite easily understandable. The game kept my interest, but did not keep the interest of my daughter, who was playing the game as well.
One disappointing thing is the lack of Johnny Depp's voice on call outs. The psuedo Captain Sparrow takes a bit to get used to, as it's just not what you are expecting to hear.
It's a lot of fun and has a number of cool features. I love the ship sinking into the playfield, if only because the kids love it, and that's what makes any game fun. I generally dislike Stern games because of the junk toys littering the playfield, but this one looks nice.
The game is smoot to play and the rules are quite easily understandable. The game kept my interest, but did not keep the interest of my daughter, who was playing the game as well.
One disappointing thing is the lack of Johnny Depp's voice on call outs. The psuedo Captain Sparrow takes a bit to get used to, as it's just not what you are expecting to hear.
Lille
8.240/10
10 years ago
A theme that casual players love to walk up to, but is it a good pin? The answer is yes. POTC gets dogged by some pinheads, but if you have played it and understand what it takes to get to the wizard mode, it is not easy at all.
Toys.....the ship is the main toy of the game and in integrated very well. Hitting the shot can prove difficult until you get the hang of hitting it a handful of times. The compass spinning disc on the top left of the machine is fun to watch and hopefully the ball will hit the stand up targets so you can start Tortuga multi ball. The chest on the right side of the playfield does get lost in the shuffle as you are mainly going for the ship and compass area, but spelling key to start heart multiball and going through the progression is a tall task. It is one of the more difficult modes to complete to light all the inserts in the middle of the playfield to reach the wizard mode.
When I first starting playing POTC, it was a brickfest....lots of standard targets on the fan layout that I seemed good at hitting, not the actual shots. Once you get the shots dialed in, the game is a blast. Trying to get a four ball Tortuga is very satisfying when you are able to get it. Stacking Tortuga and ship multiballs can see your score go up in a hurry.
A wonderful that doesn't always get its due. The price has remained high as a result. HUO only versions can still be seen going for north of NIB Stern Pro machines.....but with all the toys packed into this game, it would be a premium version these days for sure.
If I had the funds and space, would definitely own this title again.
Toys.....the ship is the main toy of the game and in integrated very well. Hitting the shot can prove difficult until you get the hang of hitting it a handful of times. The compass spinning disc on the top left of the machine is fun to watch and hopefully the ball will hit the stand up targets so you can start Tortuga multi ball. The chest on the right side of the playfield does get lost in the shuffle as you are mainly going for the ship and compass area, but spelling key to start heart multiball and going through the progression is a tall task. It is one of the more difficult modes to complete to light all the inserts in the middle of the playfield to reach the wizard mode.
When I first starting playing POTC, it was a brickfest....lots of standard targets on the fan layout that I seemed good at hitting, not the actual shots. Once you get the shots dialed in, the game is a blast. Trying to get a four ball Tortuga is very satisfying when you are able to get it. Stacking Tortuga and ship multiballs can see your score go up in a hurry.
A wonderful that doesn't always get its due. The price has remained high as a result. HUO only versions can still be seen going for north of NIB Stern Pro machines.....but with all the toys packed into this game, it would be a premium version these days for sure.
If I had the funds and space, would definitely own this title again.
Hornchurch
Sydney
7.234/10
11 years ago
Essex, ON
Couldn't wait to get this machine...searched for one...finally got to play it...was super disappointed.
The theme, the toys were awesome, yet gameplay and artwork were terrible.
The playfield colouring was not what I was expecting. VERY Primary in the red/blue/yellow's. I pictured the 7 seas to be not such a bright blue...the scroll could have been much more parchment like and the phopo shopped images were hideous. Having voice actors rather than the actual stars, really didn't sit to well - how can they use their images yet bail on the voices???
I love pirates and backalley has some great mods for this game that can really dress it up but.....
I think Stern was "close" with this title, but just missed the "boat" :)
I wouldn't mind adding this title one day to play it for longer and hopefully change my mind (I want to like it sooo bad), but not at the price it currently commands.
The theme, the toys were awesome, yet gameplay and artwork were terrible.
The playfield colouring was not what I was expecting. VERY Primary in the red/blue/yellow's. I pictured the 7 seas to be not such a bright blue...the scroll could have been much more parchment like and the phopo shopped images were hideous. Having voice actors rather than the actual stars, really didn't sit to well - how can they use their images yet bail on the voices???
I love pirates and backalley has some great mods for this game that can really dress it up but.....
I think Stern was "close" with this title, but just missed the "boat" :)
I wouldn't mind adding this title one day to play it for longer and hopefully change my mind (I want to like it sooo bad), but not at the price it currently commands.
7.964/10
11 years ago
Probably the most favorite game of guests. The sinking ship is over the top cool. Not Stern's best game (LOTR), but definitely the one with the most cool toys.
9.660/10
11 years ago
Family friendly theme. Underrated as a player IMO. Lots of neat toys crammed into this one.
7.660/10
11 years ago
I just started playing this a week or so ago...didn't like it at first, but it quickly sucked me in, and once you start to figure out what to go for and when, it really makes for a super fun game with lots of lastability. The ship and chest are both neat features, but I really like the timed lock, and Tortuga multiball. It's easy to stack with Battle with the Kraken, and can make some real good points. A nice variety of shots that will test your skills, and some that are just a death wish if you don't do it properly, but when you hit them over and over it is very very rewarding. Great game.
8.063/10
11 years ago
Pros:
Nice theme, interesting toys (I love the Chest!). Good pin with long ball times…which does not mean it is easy (how many times have you completed the 4 winds !?). Some really nice shots, including the skill shot.
Cons:
Might be repetitive after a while. Not so fan of Backglass artwork. Music is average at best. Some toys are probably fragile. Both machines I found on route had issues with the ship.
Nice theme, interesting toys (I love the Chest!). Good pin with long ball times…which does not mean it is easy (how many times have you completed the 4 winds !?). Some really nice shots, including the skill shot.
Cons:
Might be repetitive after a while. Not so fan of Backglass artwork. Music is average at best. Some toys are probably fragile. Both machines I found on route had issues with the ship.
8.940/10
11 years ago
Hensbroek
Pirates of the Caribbean is a truly fun pinball game. Owning one for over 6 months now and playing a couple of games on a daily basis! Every time with a lot of pleasure. It keeps a question why POTC is stuck in the 30+ position in the Pinside Top 100?!? It really should be rated a much higher spot.
9.020/10
11 years ago
Another Stern gem in my opinon. The sinking ship feature is sure to draw people of all ages (esecially younger ones) to the game. Other cool features such as the spinning disk of Tortuga and the Dead Man's Chest are also great eye candy which are also functional parts of the gameplay. Everytime I see one of these, I will make every effort to play a game or two if I can. Great artwork and special effects top off one on my personal top 10 pins!
You too can add your own comment by rating this game! Click here to rate this game!
Over the years
Visualizing this game's rating and rank over the years
Hey there! Welcome to Pinside!
Donate to PinsideGreat to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!
