Pinside rating

This game received 141 approved Pinsider ratings and currently rates 8.376 _/10

8.376

Top 100 ranking

This game ranks 3rd in the game group "Pirates of the Caribbean (JJP)". The group itself ranks #9 in the Pinside Pinball Top 100.

Score breakdown

Score breakdown in the 4 main categories:

Game Design: 8.329

Artwork: 8.422

Sounds/Music: 8.123

Other Aspects: 8.294

Pinside staff rating

This is how we, the very knowledgeable (wink wink) Pinside.com staff & moderators rate this game. 2 of us have rated this game.

7.985

Your Rating?

You need to be logged in before you can rate pinball machines. No account yet? Registering only takes a sec!

This game is part of a group

Note! There are multiple versions of this game!
This is "Pirates of the Caribbean".
The other versions are: Pirates of the Caribbean (LE), Pirates of the Caribbean (CE)

Found 61 ratings (with comment) on this game

There are 61 ratings (that include a comment) on this game.
Currently showing results page 1 of 3.

List options

Ratings sort order

Type of ratings to show in list

Owner status of review

Exclude flagged ratings

Keyword or username search

8.258/10

19 days ago

RIK

UCFKnight71

Pinside member

Debary, FL

1y 29,050 119 1 19

One of the better JJP games, but very much overrated. It's fun and has some good shots. I don't like the huge screens on JJP games that take away from focusing on the playfield. I also don't think widebody machines play all that great compared with standard body pins. It's fun to flip every now and then, but not a top 10 machine.

7.745/10

24 days ago

JFM

Striker

Pinside member

Alexandria, VA

2y 46,050 106 58

Really pretty game. Rules are difficult to figure out; could not determine how to make a skill shot. Widebody style hurts playability. Video screen graphics are very well done.

10.000/10

5 months ago

???

oldbaby

Pinside member

Unknown

3y 49,800 251 54

I have dreamed about this machine more than once.

7.940/10

10 months ago

JMO

PinDaddyDrain

Pinside member

Unknown

1y 25,500 1 54

I’m trying to put aside my dislike for JJP tables when I rate this…but I can’t. I will say this one is my third favorite JJP table. Second is Wizard of Oz and first is GnR. The pirate theme is cool. I’m just meh about the PotC theme.

6.856/10

1 year ago

AJC

DeprivedFallacy

Pinside member

2y 18,150 23 7 14

Played it at pinfest australia an not sure the big demand an hype for this game play wells not a normal shooting pinball theses jersey jacks different I cool them a "played movie" don't get me wrong there fun an look REALLY good but in a pinball term they shoot slower multiballs bit more clunky an they don't have the flow of a stern I've noticed same with gunners they a wicked lights how but slower machine I personally find but they make a clean classy machine none the less

2 Pinsiders flagged this.

8.860/10

1 year ago

???

JustinT

Inactive member

Bethesda, MD

1y 0 6

This is an great machine. The rocking boat is a superb feature!

9.120/10

1 year ago

PO

pat4race

Pinside apprentice

Unknown

1y 19,000 1 73

Fun game, with deep rules set; playfield is packed with features. Only downside is it’s a tough game to just walk up to in a public setting and understand all the rules and shots.

8.936/10

1 year ago

???

cdcslot

Inactive member

Unknown

2y 4,250 1 7

very good game

7.699/10

1 year ago

???

stargazor156

Pinside member

Claremont, NC

2y 22,250 2 10

It was okay there's more fun machines out there

9.580/10

1 year ago

MCH

Pinkitten

Pinside+ Member

Williamston, MI

4y 132K 2,132 23 84 3

What a game. Not since TZ in 1993 did a game feel this loaded. A true work of art and passion project by Eric M. at JJP. This game felt a bit overwhelming when it first came out, maybe even too complex for it's own good. Choosing a player from about 25 or so was complicated enough before you even plunge the ball. But once you understand how each character advantage sets up your game, it makes sense and adds plenty of variety to how you approach that game. Five movies are represented well on the playfield with 5 color coded areas, and the lights, inserts and callouts direct you during modes. Stacking movie multiballs is great, and feels like a deeper version of LOTR code. The shot variety is bonkers, like 13 main shots (that I counted) and probably more. This game is a real adventure and should keep owners busy and entertained for years. JJP is doing special things with their games. All JJP pins so far are fantastic, and this one really is the complete package. This game is dazzling and immersive even if you aren't familiar with all the movies. The only downside is they didn't make very many of these. A masterpiece.

Pinkitten edited previous rating on March 09, 2021.

10.000/10

1 year ago

YUG

Stef95

Pinside+ Member

Osny

1y 40,050 160 1 6

I have had an SE potc for a month now. This game is pure wonder. I am a fan of movies and I bought this pinball machine without having tried it before. Frankly I do not regret. I had a DI which I liked a lot but the linear and repetitive trajectories ended up boring me. The visual is splendid, the game is varied, the sequence of multiball is top. The mini tray is awesome. This pinball machine has been super well thought out. I put a 10 because for me it ticks all the boxes. This one is not ready to leave my house.

Stef95 currently owns this game.

9.900/10

1 year ago

SYD

Onwallst

Pinside+ Member

Denver, CO

6y 82,550 653 95

Wasn’t impressed at first but there are only 150 of them and when final code is here will be good.

Update:
The more I play the more I keep wanting to play more. Every character has it own strength, weakness or advantage. You can plunder and take the points from other players in the game. Great code once it was completed. I will there was still more movie clips. Seems Disney was restrictive. The rule set a d game play are top notch.

Onwallst edited previous rating on February 07, 2021.

10.000/10

1 year ago

JPM

addams40

Pinside member

Brooklyn, NY

3y 20,300 26 3 6

Game never gets old. Always finding something new.

addams40 currently owns this game.

8.000/10

1 year ago

MAT

mpdpvdpin

Pinside member

Providence, RI

4y 83,300 2,948 7 76

It’s ummm...a lot. It’s a big flashy crazy pinball experience. Do I love it though? Not really. Is it one of the wildest most involved pins design wise? Yup. Does it lack charm? Maybe. Do I think it’s a bit overrated? Kinda. I’ll give credit where it’s due, but...I don’t want it, you know? I’m not gonna buy one.

7.444/10

1 year ago

GER

Hitlow

Pinside member

Long Beach, CA

3y 28,900 10 35 19

Not a big fan of this game. I want to like it, I really do. Maybe if it we in my shop or in my home I would enjoy it more, but I did go and gave it an hour and a half of my time and I just don’t get it. If you love the theme maybe or if you have it at home. I wanted to love this game and I like was JJP is doing. I wish them all the success.

9.484/10

1 year ago

BMS

Betelgeuse

Pinside member

12y 104K 3,203 69

This game is, without a doubt, up there with the greatest pins of all time. It will likely appeal most to collectors that enjoy unique mechanical gadgets that interact with the ball, as this is easily the most loaded and complex pinball machine built to date. Every inch of the massive playfield is also utilized to the fullest with more shots than any game before it. With a steep pitch, this game still plays surprisingly fast and flowy for a widebody, even if not quite as fast as many modern Sterns. This game really feels like a new and improved version of TZ, where many games will be short and brutal until you get that one runaway ball where everything starts stacking together.
The code in this game can be a double edged sword, though. The ruleset is LotR like in it's depth, to the point where it can be daunting at first to figure out what to do. There are so many different strategies and approaches to advancing in the game, but it comes with some balancing issues. Average players will struggle to get to one of the game's 5 mini-wizard modes, which are some of the best moments in the game, while experienced tournament players may find qualifying and stacking the 6 multiball modes a little too easy. The 'chapters' and multiballs are numerous, but do have a sort of same-ness to them until you advance further in the game. Fortunately, the game has an absolutely killer musical score with many unique tracks and sounds to help set these modes apart somewhat, provided you can hear the game where you are playing.
Overall, this game provides an incredible experience unlike any other pin, especially in a home setting with the volume up and the lights down. I would highly recommend owning this game, or at least giving it some serious playtime... and I didn't even like the movies! It's become one of my new all-time favorites and we may never see another machine this complex again. A little spit and shine on the code could easily put this in my #1 spot.

10.000/10

1 year ago

PAT

Figgins

Pinside member

Ottawa, ON

4y 28,000 4 20 35

GOAT

Figgins has owned this game in the past.

2 Pinsiders flagged this.

7.888/10

1 year ago

ECW

Ecw0930

Pinside member

Fredericksburg, VA

2y 53,800 783 2 100

Huge game. A lot of game. Tons of game. Too much game? Layout seems fine. The upper flipper is either pretty useless or this one was just too weak. Soooo much going on it's so confusing for someone just wanting to play. But damn it's a great looking and themed game. I'm sure if you dive into it it's really be great. But in a public lineup and not knowing it's certainly overwhelming. To the point that you just don't want to keep coming back. It's definitely a good game, but just not for the passerby that wants to try it.

7.961/10

2 years ago

CHW

Graal33

Pinside member

2y 15,750 6

I would like to start by saying that I really like the pinball machines from JJP. I have three pinballs myself (WOZ, Hobbit and Pirates) and I am really grateful that JJP has breathed new life into the pinball machine industry.

Pirates by JJP is a good pinball machine, don't get me wrong. I just think it is overrated by many. Of my three JJP pinball machines, Pirates is clearly in last place. I will now try to explain why...

First I will start with the playfield. The Playfield layout is excellent. Many different shots, both easy and difficult. I really have nothing to complain about that. But I don't like the colors of the playfield or the airbrushed persons. I really don't find the pinball machine visually appealing... (maybe it's just me)

Now on to the gameplay for me one of the most important factors of a pinball machine:

The gameplay is ok. I like the different multiballs and I think for those who are fans of multiballs this pinball is great. I also like the fact that you can play the different multiballs together. I find the missions on the other side really boring. Collect all characters... it is always the same thing. Sometimes you have to collect three, then four or seven characters but the principle is always the same (for every movie)... (In Hobbit, for example, the missions are really intelligently done) The wizard modes for the individual movies are really great though!

The pinball machine offers a lot of toys, like the ship and the cannon which I really like! The map in the middle of the playfield is rather annoying... But that you can steal treasures, balls and points from other players is great.

The last thing I think is a pity that the music is not coming from the movies. The music is really good and varied but it would be nice if the original soundtrack would have benn used.

All in all a solid pinball machine but for me unfortunately nothing more...

7.885/10

2 years ago

LRP

lpeters82

Pinside member

11y 118K 4,815 103

There is a lot to like about the game. It is jam packed with features including amazing 3d sculpts, rocking ship playfield, treasure trunk ball lock, whirlpool ramp, interesting outlane setup, and a display that is top notch. With that said, it feels and sounds a lot like a modern slot machine where the game is designed to make you feel like you’re winning with every pull; even though you’re spending 100 credits to win 80 credits. As a location player I have a hard time understanding what shots are the most important when every insert is seemingly flashing and changing colors all the time. It’s just too much for my taste. I’m not drawn to hit the start button over and over. Perhaps it’s better in a home setting where you can really study the rules.

7.408/10

2 years ago

MED

tataye

Inactive member

Clessy

6y 16,500 16 21

l'abandon des disques central,du coffre. on jeu mal né qui penne a convaincre .le plateau basculant n'aporte pas grans chose a l'experience de jeu .bof quoi

5.664/10

2 years ago

ZAC

zacaj

Pinside member

Rochester, NY

9y 148K 9,822 70 119 4

Layout is cool but a bit clunky. Could use another pass. Code is very repetitive and random, nothing but stacking. Theme work is somehow worse than the Stern. PotC just doesn't work if you don't have the characters and clips from the movie, sorry.

11 Pinsiders flagged this.

10.000/10

2 years ago

CCC

Tigetoo

Pinside member

Riverton, UT

2y 17,650 7 9 23

JJP has set the bar high with this game I have owned dozens of pins and this tops them all. You will Play it for hours and never will know everything there is to know. Great for beginners and pros.

Tigetoo edited previous rating on October 06, 2020.
Tigetoo currently owns this game.

8.500/10

2 years ago

BAM

balt

Pinside+ Member

4y 109K 426 45

Fun to flip, beautiful playfield, tons to do. A great freshman effort by Eric Meunier. This pin earns my quarters every time I see one.

8.562/10

2 years ago

AJF

PinballTilt

Pinside+ Frequent

Akron, OH

8y 81,050 1,084 6 9

I love Pirates. I played this at a show a bunch of times and thought I hated it. Then I had an amazing game where it all clicked, the multiballs all started and I knew I had to have one. I love the way you work toward the wizard modes on this game, I love that you can choose a character with perks, I love the black pearl and it's cannon, I haven't played much with friends but plundering would be very fun with a group of friends. The biggest negative for me is the lack of assets. I would have liked to have the pirates theme music, callouts from more than 1 character, and clips with characters instead of just scenery.

PinballTilt has this game on the wishlist.

Next 1 2 3

There are 61 ratings (that include a comment) on this game. Currently showing results page 1 of 3.

You too can add your own comment by rating this game! Click here to rate this game!

Over the years

Visualizing this game's rating and rank over the years

Hey there! Welcome to Pinside!

Donate to Pinside

Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, become a Pinside+ member!