IJ does not live up to the hype that this game seems to get. This is the most overrated game from Williams in the 90's. It could be worse... but this is not Popeye.
The Pros: The sounds are great. The match/ replay with the knocker cracking the whip is perfect. Animations are sharp and well done. The 3 video modes coincide with each of the movies and are fun in their own right. The path of adventure is a great toy when working and adjusted properly. The DCS sound system on this game sounds GREAT! And the John Rhys-Davies quotes are the reason we hear him again in LotR.
The Cons: First, who is that on the BG? It certainly is NOT Harrison Ford. Did Doug Watson get in a fight with Harry's agent? Was he supposed to purposely mess this one up? I can't think of another reason because Doug is a great draftsman. One eye is about a 1/2 inch higher than the other. This is supposed to be Indiana Jones, not some bottom dwelling fish that has one eye move to the other side of it's head as it grows up. I think that this may be Harrison's mongoloid cousin Henry. You know... he posed for the Jungle Lord BG. Also, who play tested this game. The saucer rarely sticks when shot. The path of adventure is a fickle bitch if I ever met one. I'm looking for a game that plays as it should, not a needy girlfriend who needs constant maintenance just to shimmy from one side to the next. So... you get through all the modes and roll over every switch. 1 bil right? well maybe, if the game is feeling like giving you the award you just busted your hump for. So what do you do? You go for what works. Multiball and again and again and again... rinse and repeat. Hope that left flipper is strong so you can clear that right ramp. Or maybe you can go for the captive ball multi ball as well. An extremely complex and intricate game is now made up of 1-2 shots. Boring...
The Takeaway: Coming from a player's perspective, this game could have been magnificently brilliant. Why was it not brought to a finer balance to make the "journey" of the game worth it? Mark Ritchie and his team should have gotten the kinks out of the game, but they didn't and that's a real shame. The theme of this game is a great one and in some ways, the team did a good job in realizing this. However, the game play itself suffers badly. The good news is that this game is still head and shoulders above the Stern version of this theme. That's about it though and unfortunately.... The Stern version of IJ (throw it overboard arlready!) it isn't helping out the pinball cause. Overrated, overpriced and I'm over it as well. Coulda been awesome, shoulda been great... it's a fantastic game for the kids, Indiana Jones fans and collectors who enjoy spending 5 figures for an "A" list deck. Serious pin-players will get bored with the scoring strategies/bugs on this game right-quick.
Clarification:
The reason I am rating this game so low is because it is "exploitable" and has a scoring imbalance in the ruleset that takes away from the brilliant gem that this game should be. The game may look like, but it does not PLAY like a true "A" title. That is just how I feel about this deck. This is my opinion and only that. Take it for what it is.
HELLO... MYSTERY PROGRAMMER!!!
Update:
I got a chance to play a super dialed copy of this deck and I have to say that the game was a blast to play as long as we weren't looking at the score. There, I said it. Sometimes pinball is just about having fun. Scores upgraded in the name of having a great time playing pin!
Update v2:
This deck HAS to be tip-top to be playable. The mode saucer HAS to be able to hold an accurate shot to be worth shooting for. The PoA HAS to be working as it should to be worth playing. If you can get all of these things up and running as they should, this game opens up a bit more than most copies you will find in the wild. Even then, Soopa Jax are the way to go for the biggest scores in this table and while a few modes are worth points, the only ones that are really safe/worth it are Well of souls and the 3 vidja modes. There are points to be had in other modes, but the risk of playing them as compared to points to be had is not as valuable as other strategies.
Then again, you could just be playing this game for fun...