Actually, Gigli was a bad choice. The idea would seem to be "games you would actually want to play more than once", not "games you would have no problem setting on fire then pushing off the top of a twenty-story building onto someone's BMW for a laugh".
I think a Tribute To Vincent Price game would be good, but would that be better as an EM or DMD?
Hellblazer (DC, NOT that Keanu Reeves WTF movie) might have some potential.
And an H.P. Lovecraft game would be fun right up to the point the Mystery Award turned out to be one of Cthulhu's face tentacles reaching out of the backglass straight into your brain...