Quoted from jeffspinballpalace:

Choosing 5 pins to capture your attention and reflect your pinball tastes is tuff. Paying $61k for them is a big commitment too.
AFMLE - best Bally/Williams was made even better by CGC. Strobe multiball, mothership video mode, 5-shot combo insert (encouraging combos since 1995), solid dialog and humor, scoring in XX billion point range - $9k.
JJPOTCLE - best adventure game ever - infinite combinations. Eric Menier design rarely found on location - $25k
JJPGNRLE - best pin ever made. Eric Menier design. - $11k
MET prem - best Stern dmd. Great toys - Sparky bash toy, moving hammer, newton ball coffin lock, ball swallowing snake lock and white cross rising from the grave. Dirty Donnie art. Lots of cool game mods available - $8k
JP2 - Keith Elwin design and my fave mega-theme. Zombie Yeti art. Community ROM with “real” movie assets create new level of integration - $8k
Two game types I see lacking from my selections are a fast / brutal game and a quirky game that somehow feels different. Adding them to round out the package would increase costs to $73k.
IM - Iron Man is fast and unforgiving - $6k
DP pro - I love the zigzag ramp, snikt multiplier target, Zombie Yeti art. New display graphics were created. Humor. - $6k

Quoted from Cantabkiwi:

In not set order...
TNA
Tron
Ironman
Rick and Morty
Shadow