Quoted from jfh:You are absolutely correct. But you stopped after the $10k offer and gave no indication you were interested in going higher. Since you are ok quoting our PMs, here are the two messages after your offer:
JFH:
"$10k would not be enough incentive for me to sell - I would just keep it (and probably cancel MMR). I really hadn't thought of a price, but I get offers of $12k fairly often (without advertising), so it would probably be north of that. In the range of an MMR + another NIB game is probably what would interest me"
teekee:
"I understand… beautiful MM for sure but out of my range. With everything that is happening in the hobby with remakes and re-runs and who knows what else will happen. I just have a hard enough time paying $10k plus for anything let alone a pin that is being re-made. I think it is worth it for sure since there are probably so few true HUO MM left but I wouldn't be comfortable paying much more than 10. If anything changes let me know otherwise I will say patient and see what happens after the MMr release."
No other offer after 10 - fine, I understand. But that said to me that you valued my game at 10 and if you were saying 10 plus, the logical conclusion wasn't worth 10 plus to you. I had no way to know you would offer 12, because you said it was "out of your range".
I don't think my comments were unfair at all.
It's your thread ... You can offer whatever you want for whatever kind of game you want. I'm pretty sure mine is the nicest original unrestored MM out there (or very close), so the plus must require more (e.g. HEP detailing)
The plot thickens...