I did a horror theme with pins for awhile...They're are some great titles to be had. I had at one time:
as my line up...Just down to MC, SS, TFTC and CFTBL now.
For inexpensive horror themed games and really good players, concentrate on TFTC, MSF and EATPM. BSD is approaching A title status, and CFTBL, SS, MB, TAF are full entrenched at the high end.