Tommy would be my choice - very good playfield layout with plenty of satisfying shots make it a very fun game to play. The combo shots are very fun and fast. The mode variety is good. The blinders are a brilliant toy that change the entire game when in action - try hitting the loops with these on is very difficult and fun! Tommy looks great in most environments too. Tommy with the pinsound board re orchestrations makes it a top 20 game for me. Tommy will continue to rise in value because of the new software and Pinsound.
POTC and Sopranos are good games, but don't have near the long term replay factor compared to Tommy in my opinion.
**Unfortunately, I have never played WPT. The WPT as shown in the pictures looks great.