Quoted from Rarehero:At the heart of most criticism is context.
-Jack claimed that Stern was making product no one wanted & he couldn't sell. Clearly that's not the case anymore...AC/DC BIB LE's and TRON LE's are sought after and people pay 10k plus for them. Even Iron Man is now being sought after & people are begging Stern to re-run it.
-Jack claimed Stern flippers can't get the ball up a ramp unless you push and beat on the game. Stern flippers are fine, yet WOZ's have been less than optimal at most show appearances.
-Jack claimed he wouldn't ship a game with unfinished code...it's starting to look highly likely that that will happen
-Jack's motto is "under promise and over deliver" ....yet nothing has been delivered yet, so...
There's just been so much fluff, and eventually some of these words and actions have become ironic or even hypocritical....it's ammo. I don't think anyone who uses that ammo (even Exejet) is just purely an evil person who is rooting for failure. I think most people feel like they were told "Stern blows, forget about them, I'm going to make the best game ever...join my wonderful club of pinball nirvana" ...that game isn't out yet, but they're having tons of fun with games like AC/DC and Tron. They've played WOZ at shows and it's don't find it to be that that fun (in its current state) compared to Stern's games which have been knocked down as horrible, undesirable, weak-flippered crap - almost in a religious proselyting fashion . So, the negative attitude is a response to the various ironies of the entire endeavor, and a backlash to the cult-like nature of the "JJP can do no wrong" cheerleaders. The extremes are clashing. Jack just really built up some insane expectations and now we're in reality-land.
Your reasoning at the end makes total sense, but I disagree with some of the context.
First point: Stern pinball is not in "high demand" anymore. It is a niche market, with only a scant few hundred of the various LEs being made/sold per title. High demand would approach the 5-10k title runs, but those days have passed. The real-world demand for new pins has fizzled, with much of it shifted from operators to the collector market, a tough market to sustain a maker of high-priced toys. And the collector interest in places like Pinsie skew the big-picture state of the world pinball market. Total sales volume matters more than anything. JJP is going for mass appeal and broader sales, with operator incentives, etc. It remains to be seen how successful that will be, of course.
Flippers? They are clearly still working n the available adjustments; seems like the early test games didn't even have adjustability. Nobody knows how the flippers will play on production machines until they ship (with sufficient control code).
Unfinished code? Yeah, I agree that the code will likely have several updates after the game ships. How unfinished will it be? Dunno, but I suspect there are more pieces done that haven't yet been implemented in the test games.
Not over-delivering? Yup, can't tell for sure until the final game is delivered. But I already see a ton of over-delivered stuff that was not promised when I bought in way back when. Stuff like a crystal ball with embedded video; full bottom rails on an easily-removeable playfield; a killer 150 wpc sound system with 7 drivers; Full-spectrum controllable LED lights for all inserts; a classy wooden apron cover; 5 flippers and a bunch of magnets; 11-ply plywood; hi-res clearcoated cabinet art; etc. Pretty sure we haven't even seen the LE topper yet. And I have no doubt that the WOZ rules will be incredible.
Yeah, I can understand why many are frustrated with the time this project is taking. But the jury is still out, and I think the game will be better than what people are expecting now.