Quoted from lowepg:So does Robin throw out the folks that rated a game a 10?
That seems to be just as much an "outlier" as someone who rates a game very low.
If not, its just adding even more subjectivity to the process....
Well
If let's say a game is a solid 8.5 good game, someone votes it a 10 that's not as bad as voting it 1.0 which means worse possible in every single category.
Also if a game has lights, and the work fine maybe the best ever such as STLE, how can it be voted worse ever or next to worse ever in that category? But it can easily be voted best.
Now with STLE it might not have the best dots but certainly not the worst of all time, or the worse theme integration etc... I mean it can not possibly integrate the movies better, it recreates actual scenes from the movies with actual sound clips, what more do you want? How can that be rated worst ever?
I never vote any pin perfect 10 seems silly always has to be something less than 100% but some might not agree and vote a lot of best in category.
Even a bad pin like South Park, I didn't rate that but likely would be 5.6 or something suitably low, I think it stinks but not 1.4 stinks, I can not fathom 1.4 rating on STLE, art, sound, rules, lights, layout all superior to South Park without a doubt that's not subjective it's a fact.