I voted neither.
I've owned Stern POTC and have played JJPPOTC. I'm all pirated out.
Same with BK3. I already own BK and BK2K. I'll play BK3 at some point, but I'm not dying to have one. In fact, my mini BK collection might be on the block at some point.
I'm waiting for Elvira's House of Horrors and Toy Story.