BK3, even not having played it. Several reasons:

1. POTC is too easy. Even on the proto with the spinning discs that added a ridiculous amount of randomization and some really harsh STDM drains, I played on that thing on my very first game for 30-45 minutes, and played all the main multiballs, some of them more than once.

2. Price. JJP cannot compete with Stern, and I don't personally feel like the differences in their games are worth an extra 2-4k.

3. Theme. BK is kinda proven, and with it looking like BK3 is going to maintain most of the feel of BK2000 with it being a little campy and cheesy, that wins over a series of movies I've only seen half of.

That's a fair point, and I leave it to others to make that decision for themselves. I felt like Hobbit was extremely easy as well, WOZ to a lesser degree, and Dialed In is the hardest game JJP has made. This is all depending on the game playing properly in the first place, of course, which seems to be a major problem with JJP games. Weak flippers just absolutely screw over these games more than Sterns for some reason.