pezpunk- I'm curious to know your opinion of Umphrey's mcgee.

While I do agree that IMO Kiss as a band kind of sucks, they are certainly nowhere near the 2nd worst band of all time. I also have no desire to have Gene Simmons autograph. That said, if I was local and I owned a Piss pin new or old I probably would shell out the $120 bucks. I don't know if it would add value per say, but it could certainly be the deciding factor for making the sale down the road or at the very least a little extra incentive for somebody to buy your game.