Quoted from JediPimp:
Thanks everyone for your help. I was able to get new screws from PinballSpareParts and a new nut plate from Marcos Pinball.
I also went ahead and ordered the metal goalie mod from PinballPT on eBay.
What’s everyone’s opinion of the metal goalie mod?
i got him, because my plastic guy was more glue than plastic at this point. I really like it, haven't had any issues with it at all, no longer have to worry about parts breaking off and falling into the goal and jamming things up. and I don't see it hitting any harder or deflecting any harder or anything like that. can barely tell the difference which is what I was hoping for. And I got to get my guy in the Germany outfit so I can take him down!