Hobbit is a real love it or hate it type game. I feel that most people don't enjoy it. It's also a shooters game, meaning you really need to dial in your shots. I love the audio visual package, and yes it is wide, but when you get Smaug going (and other things), it is a total blast.

Having said that, Pat Lawlor is one of my favorite designers. Wonka is fun too. I don't know if I've even ever seen the Wonka movie, but the audio package in the game didn't do it for me. It's all over the place. Hard to compare the two. I'm going to +1 what joelbob said.

My honest and probably unpopular opinion is that Dialed In would be my Pat Lawlor game of choice based on layout.