I get a kick out of these posts....what one likes or dislikes about a pinball game is really a personal decision. Some people like fast, fun, and exciting games with deep rule sets, and some are drawn to the theme of the machine. The good news is both of these games are themed based, and will resonate with different audiences. I have owned both machines, and they are both very fun games, but very different from each other. I would pick the game that has the best theme in your mind.