Does the reset relay remain energized? If so, the reset sequence has not completed.
Look at the schematic to see what will make the reset relay drop:
- the four reels must be at zero (and the zero switch must correctly open for each reel)
- the advance unit must be at the zero position
- a make/break switch must open when the score motor turns
Only once all three of these are true will all pathways to energize the reset relay be open (via the self-hold switch on the reset relay)