Hi Max
Your post-14: Very strange, frustrating. In this post-15 I do NOT write about testing on the mystery --- some general words:
Our problem is: We believe Your saying is true - Your saying "when no Extraball is gained - the (regular) ball is lost: Ball-Index-Relay ALWAYS let go at the time the pin kicks the next ball over to the shooter alley".
IF (if, if, when) we can prove "Your saying is NOT TRUE --- SOMETIMES the Ball-Index-Relay does NOT let go": We then can investigate in "post-5, JPG, dark-green-6, -7, -8".
It is not much fun having the playfield up - simulating "lifetime of a ball" by manually making points - maybe gaining an Extraball, simulating "ball gets lost" - staring at the Ball-Index-Relay , staring at other stuff --- doing so for some hundreds of games. No, not much fun.
Much better is "You have the playfield down and You play - You really play - You like Your pin and You play some many games --- and You have an added Information-Light that shows You "Ball-Index-Relay is pulling (Information-Light is lit)" - and tells You "Ball-Index-Relay is not pulling as the Information-Light is unlit". You play many games and at the time the pin kicks-out a new ball: You look at the Information-Light - lit or unlit ? AND WHEN the result is: SOMETIMES the Information-Light STAYS lit: You would have proven "SOMETIMES the Ball-Index-Relay does NOT let go: We then can investigate in post-5, JPG, dark-green-6, -7, -8".
That Information-Light - please make Yourself one and mount*** it --- here https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/reading-gottlieb-schematics in post-12 "SteveFury" shows his Test-Light (I then made myself this handy tool), You also see it in the upper right corner of my JPG. To mount*** it in Your pin: Have the two bulbs in the outside - taped to the pin, the two long wires run through the open coin-door to "Coil on Ball-Index-Relay" - one gator-clip (of the "wire to the bulbs") is clipped-on at "left side-solder-lug of the coil" --- and the other gator-clip () is clipped-on at "right side-solder-lug of the coil" (((You have mounted the Test-Light PARALLEL to / with the Coil))) --- when the Ball-Index-Relay is pulling: Testlight is lit and when the relay is not pulling: Testlight is unlit.
Make Yourself such an Testlight and use it and "prove right" or "prove wrong" the mentioned "Your saying". Do this "playing and looking at the Testlight / Information-Light" BEFORE You cut / desolder wires. I hope for "SOMETIMES the Ball-Index-Relay does NOT let go: We then can investigate in post-5, JPG, dark-green-6, -7, -8".
If "No luck at all": We can do some add-on / little alteration to MAKE the Extraball-Relay quit pulling: See in the JPG the "red N" Microswitch --- we can mount such an microswitch (I made this about a year ago on a pin) - mount in the way the "rod of launching a given new ball" can go through the opening of the micro-switch --- for "to launch the ball" You pull the rod therefore the ball rolls a bit and by that rolling down a bit: Actuates the microswitch.
We can make a little alteration so Your problem dissapears - still: I would like to find the fault ...
I wait for result of "using a Testlight mounted parallel to the Coil on Ball-Index-Relay" - EVERY time a Ball is kicked over to the shooter alley and rest there to be launched: Test-Light MUST be unlit --- unlit if You have gained an Extraball or if You have "not gained an Extraball" --- EVERY time: MUST be unlit, greetings Rolf
855-enriched (resized).jpg