The code was terrible on initial release. Perhaps that has played into the ratings?
I hated it when it was released. Found it very boring. I honestly thought code couldn't save the game and didn't enjoy the shots.
Fast forward to the last code release and it really changed everything. Really opened my eyes to the importance of code. I realized good code could make a decent game incredible, but really didn't think a crappy game could become awesome.
TWD is an awesome game. I disagree with Hazoff. The Pro is great value and it's the version I plan on buying some day. I play the game on location and have found it holds up well.