It isn't just because of the depth, it is the fact that the code matches the physical brutality perfectly. It is in the combination of brutal play that the excellent software starts to shine. It kind of makes you feel like you actually are in a zombie apocalypse.
You can't think of it in terms of a normal game software which has something for everyone. It is only those fleeting adrenaline fueled moments where it shines. I played that game a ton, and it never clicked. Then with newer versions of the software I again tried to like it, and the match is amazing. Sometimes the game design and software design just work together. This one does that extreamly well. So when people say it is one of the best coded Stern games, it all comes down to addictive nature of the game where physical and software collide.