Quoted from Rabscuttle:I would really love some tips. I have a hell of a time with it, partly because my arms aren't amazingly muscular or anything. I feel like I'm at a disadvantage for nudging to begin with. I am pathetic at it, and I really want to get better at pinball.
As the OP mentioned, if you're putting weight on your palms, i.e. using the game as a giant walker, then forward nudging is really a non-starter.
I made a nudging basics video. I threw it together for a presentation or something and should probably make a better one, but you might find some of it useful.