Quoted from rad:Interested in opinions from Tesla S and/or 3 owners... If you were considering purchasing a used S (85D or 90D with under 25k miles) versus a 3, would you pick the 3 or a used S (85/90D) and why? What options(s) would you make sure to get?
Thanks in advance.
I've had my 3 for about 7 months and I was given a Model S for 2 weeks while my 3 was in the shop. I would recommend driving both to figure out which one you prefer.
TLDR: If I were given the choice between a 3 (LR) and an S (70D) for the same price, I would still get the 3. A lot of this is personal preference and circumstance so your situation may be (and likely is) different.
I'll try to go over the differences that mattered to me and why I like or dislike each:
Suspension: S has an air ride system that allows you to adjust car height, 3 has traditional coil suspension. Very early 3 production had some complaints, I know they changed their seats since then to make a better feeling ride. I couldn't tell the difference and thought they both felt good. I'm sure others can notice the difference, I just didn't
Size: The S is noticeably wider than the 3 by ~6 inches, also nearly a foot longer. If you're planning on carrying multiple adults, maybe this is a good thing. Here in the bay area where parking spots are super tiny, I found it much easier to park in the 3 and didn't have to worry as much about people opening their door into my car.
Screens: The S has the dash cluster screen which is definitely nice. The maps implementation there could be better, but if I had the choice, I would rather have this screen behind the dash and the 3 doesn't. The main screen is a different story. The S has a terrible tile/split screen system compared to the 3 which allows for sliding apps like music up or down to increase the size or get rid of it entirely. much more intuitive, much more fluid, way more options, and looks better too. The main screen is a clear win for the 3
Center Console: The 3 has one large well with lid plus a decent size bucket under the arm rest. I use the larger space for storage including charging adapter. I use the space under the arm rest for electronics and battery for a dashcam. The S has a large customizable divider system taking up most of the center that is not hidden. The 3 is my clear preference but it's very specific to my personal use case.
Door Handles: The 3 handles look neat, they work fine, they do attract too many finger prints on and around them. I like them... but the Model S door handles that pop out are just way cooler.
Phone vs car fob: The 3 uses your phone (via bluetooth) to unlock your car and allow it to start (or you can use the credit-card rfid tags) while the S uses a fob in the shape of a model S that you carry on your keys. I definitely like using my phone much better. I always have my phone on me so I don't have to carry anything extra. I usually don't carry any keys so I found the S fob to be kind of annoying. There is now a car fob option for the 3 as well I believe for $150
Range: My extended range 3 gets 310 miles to the charge. I only charge it to 90% so that's 279 miles. The S 70D I drove had a range of 259 miles. charged to 90% is only 233 miles. I get nervous getting below about 50 miles (and so I don't) which really gives my model 3 an effective 229 miles/charge compared to the S 178 miles/charge. I found that 25% less miles/charge to be a huge difference. Sure you can get a longer range S, but that's a lot more money. Also I don't have a charger at home. I charge at work about once per week. If you charge the car every day at home, this might not matter to you at all.
Trunk/cargo: The trunk on the S closes with the push of a button, the 3 is manual. That's just an extra feature for the S that the 3 doesn't have and I wish it did. Both cars have very large trunks (as well as smaller frunks). They both also have a large tub below a hatch in the trunk which is nice to hold groceries etc. While both cars have a ton of storage, the S somehow has TWICE as much. I've seen a pinball machine loaded in the back of an S which you definitely can't do with a 3. the S is a hatchback which helps with this. Bottom line: both have crazy storage, but if you for some reason need even more or the larger opening of a hatchback, the S is the way to go.
Additional Notes: I don't have the Performance version of the 3 and had a 70D model S, don't know how the performance versions compare. The air filter in the 3 works well, the S is supposed to have a crazy large HEPA filter which works better. Never tested it. I have tried EAP and thought it was terrifying. It missed objects in the road and drifted a bit too much for my comfort. I did NOT pay for EAP nor Full auto. In my opinion, full auto will never be viable for current S or 3 models. It will be at a minimum years away and certainly require additional hardware (and that's IF it ever comes which I think it won't) so I have taken all self-driving concerns out of my decision process, but if you disagree, obviously that could change your preferences.