Quoted from taylor34:LOTR would be a good seller at $5k, but if they jacked it to 5.5k they'd be met with a lot less interest. I know at 5k I'd probably be in. It basically can't be more expensive than what a HUO one costs today or it won't fly.
After MMR, I fear the days of sub-$5000 pins are gone. $5,000-$6000 will probably be the new norm.
Stern probably makes a new pin for about $2100, sells it to distributors for $4100 and distributor sells to you for $5499.
The remakes cost much less to produce with licensing taking a decent chunk. There is much less backend expenses, R&D, testing, etc so their cost of making the machine perhaps drops to $1700.
These numbers are just guesses, probably no one knows for sure. But LOTR VE makes sense because the cost of production is lower and it would be wildly popular.