Quoted from PinMonk:
I transferred it to a new wheel. I think I used gentle heat, but I may have used freeze spray, I don't recall.
You WILL need to put some new 467MP on the back to refresh the adhesive of the sticker for the new wheel, though.
Digikey has a 5 yard roll, 3" wide for $18. Should last you a long time for these kinds of projects. I have a giant roll (50 yards? 100 yards?) of 3" I got like 20 years ago that I'm not even 1/2 way through.
Had a little adventure getting the 467MP tape... Digikey main base is about 2 hours away but it's finally here.