Almost all of the Stern games are fun. Even the ones that get ranked on here have a lot of redeeming qualities to their play. And the ones that are not as good end up getting priced accordingly. So honestly you will probably not go wrong.
Quoted from brucipher:I know it gets a ton a love, but I kind of can't stand Metallica's music...so there's that
I don't like their music that much either, but the pin doesn't get love because of the music, it gets love because of the rules. Once you learn the rules, the game is very approachable, and extremely fun. It allows you to choose between risk reward shots, and it lets you keep a jackpot on the table in CIU to build up a crazy jackpot (along with double scoring if you line it up right). I love a game that can give you that kind of decision and you end up knowing exactly how many points you will lose if you flub it.
But maybe that isn't a good fit. However there are lots of choices. Pick the rule style you like, and then pick a game to match it.