All of the companies listed here (and a few not listed) are great people.
I will agree with the post stating about getting the cheapest price though. Cheapest price, best service, and follow up after the sale... you can generally get 2 of the 3, but rarely will you get all 3
As for the sales tax, it all depends on the distributor and how much they sell into any given state. Regardless on of the distributor collects sales tax or not, it is still your responsibility to declare and pay your state's sales tax for "out of state purchases." The "I bought it out of state" line wont hold much water when the department of revenue starts looking.
I would also agree with the poster that suggested finding someone local to deal with. These are the companies (generally) that are supporting your local shows, local establishments with prizes for tournaments, and are able to offer a trade in program since there isn't a lot of shipping involved. Local also means they have an easier time if something goes wrong with the game. We can all do service virtually, but that is also dependent on your skill level. For example, I can easily troubleshoot and determine you have a blown transistor, but if you dont have the skills to remove and install a new one, then all my help doesnt do you any good. That being said, newer games have less and less soldering required, but that's just an example. Here's a real life one. I recently sold (locally) an Avengers Infinity Quest pro and the opto for the right ramp exit went out. The customer had neither the desire nor the skills to replace this, so now what? They would have had to call in someone at $100 an hour (or more) to do a 15 minute job.
There are lots of variables that come into buying a game from anyone. If you dont need the local service (install, repairs, trade ins, etc) then buy from whomever takes the time to make you feel like you are am actual customer and not just another number.
In the end, there are a lot of great dealers out there, just make sure you stick to the official, authorized dealers and not the guys who claim to be, but are not.
If you wish to continue this conversation let me know
[email protected]