We allow make ups in the league I'm in, and I have hosted folks when they are making up their games. I'm honestly not a competitive person by nature but since other guys are and I'm a stickler for following rules I would not have offered up that advice regardless of the skill level of that player. Not while he was playing his make-up games. Before or after, probably might have. I also don't share the other scores in that person's group until they finish their game since they already have the advantage of playing by themselves without the distraction of other people around. We don't require that the make-up person play against someone else, probably not a bad idea but usually when someone is making up they tend to be in a hurry to get it over with.

If they were doing that, at that exact same moment and situation when the other players were playing their turn, then I would agree. As it is in this example this guy is getting "help" that the others didn't. Yea, I see your point, it's just explaining rules of the game. But then again, if the host wasn't doing that for the other players the day before it seems like an advantage.