Pirates of the Caribbean.
I actually like the game just fine, the ship is a cool toy, and the Tortuga multi ball is really fun, but I was disappointed how generic it was, and especially that it was totally lacking the movie soundtrack (licensing, I know... fixable now thanks to Pinball Browser!) and the super generic call outs with the occasional terrible Jack Sparrow impersonation.
There are worse games (Stern IJ, I'm looking at you) but I feel like Pirates really missed the theme.