The Shadow, but that's probably not a real surprise to anyone by now.
Quoted from Concretehardt:Man I need to find a Shadow to play... I've never even seen one in person
Heh, ironically mine came from Eugene, sorry! There's a reason you see it listed several times in this thread, people like Lyman wax on about it, it's just a special game in a lot of ways. Not for everyone, and it's not an easy game, but nothing else quite like it.
I think the Baldwin thing just hung like a weight around its neck. When I did my translite I had people PM me to say they bought a Shadow because of it, which is obviously flattering, but really does speak to how the original translite held it back. The rest of the theme is great, it's one of my favs not just in general but for the callouts and music too.