For me it's 1976 Volley, hands down. I love drop target games. Joker Poker, Cleopatra, Count-Down, et al. But the oldest one that I love the most has got to be Volley.
Quoted from SantaEatsCheese:Paragon
One of the best games ever made. I just had mine restored. New playfield, backglass, plastics, posts, rubbers, etc. If this is how the game played brand new, holy cow.