I sold a decent 100% working one with topper and card mech for $1350. It had a few dings, a little surface rust, and a little cabinet fade but no hacks. I spotted someone in the next state who posted that they just missed a deal on one, told them about mine, and sold it fast.

Mine sold fast at 1350. Hard to find them that cheep working and clean. Maybe 100 less without the topper and card mech.

Its all about condition....somewhere between $1200-$2500.....some actually have a color dmd installed, working card mechs, and are in great working condition....

Around $1500

I think mine was $1500 with card dispenser but no topper.

If I was a betting man it’s going to keep going up. Easily the top 5 games played at my house by family and friends. $1300 for a working WPC game that has location value is NUTS in 2019

My slugfest is on location. Makes a little money

Mine does more than a little money. Incorporate drinking games with it. It works

Around $1500 seems to be the magic number, give or take a few hundred depending on condition and what's missing/present. $1500-$1700 seems to move at some point, but it may sit for a bit. Below that, and it tends to move pretty quickly.

$2k+ is way too high for an average example missing stuff.

A repro topper is cheap. Nobody is altering price because it's missing.
For many, the card dispenser is pointless, so someone may not knock a whole lot off for that either.
I valued mine at $1950, no topper, little to no fade, new overlay, all leds. No idea if the dispenser worked, the bat was rebuilt by me.

It landed up going In a trade deal with another pin, but I had more interest in it than any other machine I've ever listed. There was a serious amount of trade offers.
If my kids were older I would have kept it, but it is no fun single player.
There isn't many of them, so you may not have a ton of options for price.
If it looks and plays right, $1500-$2000.

Never even made an ad, simply mentioning it once in the northeast for sale section generated plenty of interest.

one sold at auction recent for $1100. you could bid online or in person.

Keep in mind that those online auctions usually carry a buyer's premium of around 23-28%

So, the full/final price would have been somewhere around $1353-$1408.

Additionally, most auction games (especially when not in a coinop auction) are usually projects to varying degrees, so they wouldn't fetch as much as a fully working & shopped game.

Most if not all of these games were on location (and thus beat up) so value really is a function of condition. I looked for months to find one that was in decent shape as most were beat to shit. That being said its a pretty easy game to work on and maintain although parts are not easy to find, and fixing these games adds up pretty quickly. I paid $1600 for mine (it had LED's, good boards, original topper, working card dispenser), and then spent about $700 in upgrades to get the game in perfect working order. I added new red trim (cheap), card chute (not easy to find), bat mech, new bat, flipper mech, balls, new CPO (hard to find), and a color DMD (which is awesome and a big upgrade)....If I spent the $250 for new decals my machine would look almost new, but its a total pain in the ass. My guess is I'd have a good chance to get my $ back if I decided to sell the game.

Same as any other game...the more you pay, the nicer it should look. Do you have any pictures of it?

anyone have a panel overlay for these ?

Looking to sell mine but a bit of a hike from you. All new LED's, new CPO, T-moulding,new legs, card dispenser works with two card chutes(one blue one black) lots of extra vintage baseball cards. PM for details

Planetary had the cpo last time i checked.
And a guy in the slugfest post makes people card chutes.

Planetary is out of the CPO (they have been for over a year)....I would suggest asking them when they might print some up...the CPO isn't easy to find (unfortunately)

Mike has some slugfest cpos- I can pm your his number

It's easy to LED. I found that adding a few frosted white LED to the GI above the bat was useful to make the pitch easy to see, and skipped the rest. The inserts look fine with incandescent bulbs, except for the 4 blue ones. I installed 4 blue LEDs for those.

Changing out the cards on display in the back box takes a fair amount of disassembly.

if your used to working on pinball machines anything on slugfest is pretty easy....changing the cards in the display is easy it just takes some disassembly....LED's are a piece of cake....

Edit

Control Panel Overlay. I have 2 NOS ones on my shelf. Anyone?

I have a box of nos parts also (small parts) I'll post in classified list?

Well, since were going there.
I have the NOS plastic set. 2 apron pieces, fence, crowd. The other 3 to.
I can make someone a good deal.
I will pull it out and make an ad to.

Wish you had these 2 years ago when i was looking for the CPO. Game gone now.

In reply to all the messages. The overlay has a clear 'spray' of something medium shiny. Maybe residue from the protective film? I am attempting to show it
IMG_6659 (resized).JPGIMG_6661 (resized).JPG I can try to wax it off?

thats was all in with fees and it worked, i saw it in person.

I should have a couple over lays. Let me look and see. I believe they are originals.