I've been a mostly electric smoker just because of the convenience. But, have really only done pork since there is such a HUGE temperature swing with them (at least based on the 2 I've had). Was going to go pellet and go cadillac (Recteq) but really liked what I saw with regards to the Masterbuilt vertical charcoal units that were talked about earlier in this thread. Never got a close out deal at Walmart. But decided to go "cheap" and pull the trigger on a smaller (560 sq in) unit at Home Depot. Did a break-in and monitor with my wifi thermometer over the weekend.
Definitely a temperature offset from the location of the thermometer the PID controller uses but very stable. Probably a definite swing across the cooking surface with the side closest to the firebox being hottest. You guys can chime in but I don't think this is unusual. Pellet smokers with center heat sources might have more even heat but I would think any offset smoker would be hotter closer to the fire.
Basically, I look at this as essentially an "automatic" offset-fire smoker.
Anyway, excited to try this new badboy out. Based on the reviews I've seen this may not last more than a couple years, but I take pretty good care of my kit so we'll see. I also don't intend to use it as a regular grill at all so maybe using just lower temps will help that. I really just got this for smoking as I'm still quite happy with my 20-year old Jenn-Aire gas grill for grilling. I've got an egg-knock-off for when I really want chargoal for grilling.
Anyway, happy morning all and GRILL ON!
Jaz