I am in a very similar situation. We have a ST Prem and have had a GOT LE for about 6 weeks. Unlike you, selling the ST was never something we considered. As for the GoT, if it were up to me I would have gotten the premium to save money, but my wife was really into the show and loved the artwork and Targaryen theme on the LE and the money wasn't a big issue. An added advantage of getting the LE is that we got it much sooner than if we had ordered the prem (would likely still be waiting), although I doubt this will be an issue for those ordering now. So for me the GoT LE was worth the extra, but it would depend a lot on how much money you had, how much your wife preferred the LE, etc. There will also be aftermarket translight and side armor options for the prem which in my opinion will make that machine look better although some will prefer the stock look. Our GoT LE has been played a ton, I would guess approaching 1,000 plays at this point. We both love the game, and think it is the best in our collection although it is a difficult call at this point because it is so new. I still play ST. It is a different game and a game I still enjoy (sounds like more than you do from your comments). Since ours is a premium with Aurich's art package I feel it would be very difficult to replace. Replacing a stock ST pro would likely be easier in the future if you decided you needed to have one. So I guess if your situation is similar to mine I would keep ST and get the GoT LE.