Quoted from dangermouse007:Terminator 2,Dracula,Indianajones(williams),Dr who
First of all... I LOVE THAT LINEUP!
LOTR is a chore. Fish Tales is fun, but it has too much in common with IJ.
Whitewater is a really upbeat fun game and would complement your death and danger lineup extremely well. It would be my first choice.
If you are thinking that depth is really the goal, then the Shadow might make more sense.