ABBA would be amazing.
I'm all about pinball quirk so my dream themes are pretty random:
Antiques Roadshow
Great British Bake Off
Price is Right
Deadwood
Snowpiercer
Star Trek Lower Decks or Disco
Stardew Valley, Celeste, Spelunky, Hades, Outer Wilds, Yoku's Island, Overcooked, FTL, Cuphead or some other sort of collaboration with a popular indie video game dev. There is so much good art and music being made by individuals and small teams (that have sold millions of games) that could bring a ton of new awesome stuff to pinball.