VIPER!
Based off your past cars and the ones that you sound to lean towards it really fits the bill nicely. They are super fun to drive, easy to work on and still look modern (most people that don't know Vipers think my 98 is brand new).
I was hesitant to get one because of the "they will kill you comments" but it's one of the easiest fast cars I've ever driven. Don't do something stupid and floor it going around a corner and you are fine.