Play them, and wait for manufacturers to produce additional grail pins for you.

This is the correct answer but I would have also accepted

A. Rub them with a diaper
or
B. Put lots of dolls and LED's into them

Give it time. That fulfillment will dwindle and a new pin will be purchased.

I perfectly happy with a six pin lineup. I don't feel like my collection has any major holes or anything like that, but there is always this constant itch to mix things up. I currently have a Total Nuclear Annihilation, Metallica, Congo, The Shadow, Hardbody, and Gold Strike. I'd like to keep a "rotating spot" in my lineup, but I enjoy everything I own at this point. I have a fear that I will be moving onto a game that I like less, but at the same time I really only discover how I feel about a game after I own it for a few months. Thus my desire to bring in a new game every 6 months. It pains me to say, but either Congo or The Shadow is likely going to be the spot that opens up.

Pursue other games. Part of the fun is the trill of the hunt.

Also, bring them to shows to share.

Yep - grail pin stays (WOZ) and I keep adding tasteful mods to keep it fresh. My collection has shrunk due to downsizing our house so the 3 pin lineup has to have variety. If I sell our (the wife’s) Galaga/Ms Pac-Man arcade I can fit one more pin... I’m thinking about a JJP 4 pin grail lineup, but that would involve selling the wife’s TZ which she rarely plays....
It’s that or finish the basement and have the mancave with more pins... such a struggle

Keep buying pins hoping they don't suck. When they don't live up to your two grail pins..donate them to a good cause. Me.

Sit here. Happy they are in my line up.

LTG : )

Identify the next grail game and search for it!

I have a grail list. When I get a game from the list, they all move up one spot. This list is never ending just prioritized.

Get better grail pins.

I felt a bit the same, then I played Hoodini over the weekend!!!!WOAH!!!

Honestly, if you are happy with your collection and don't have the itch to buy something new, enjoy it. I wish I could get rid of that itch.

Find more grail pins

I’ve been through my grail games. And now I’ve changed my buying style to “opportunistic” buying. I’m not actively shopping for a TWD, but if I happen upon one, I’ll bring it home. Occasionally I run across a classic I haven’t owned yet, and if it’s good value, it comes home too. But I’m not shopping. I never look at CL unless a friend texts me something. It’s a nice relaxed state of Pinball.

For a while, I did keep enhancing the games I owned, but now I prefer clean and playing well over anything I could add to them.

Overall, play, have fun, share them with friends. Enjoy.

Play them.

"Thrill of the hunt" only leads you to hoarding and spending too much.

Thrill of play makes it worth it.

For some of us I believe we become Steward and Carekeepers of machines. I have let a few go to people that have a Passion for a title.

I have been very fortunate to have 90% of the titles that I have wanted. Thanks to the hard work of CGC and others 1 more of my grail pins will arrive at a reasonable price. Hopefully they will deliver before Christmas but I'm patient.

Sometimes your Grail pin becomes like a boat anchor and you realize O-sh!t this was not as cool as I thought. Cirqus Voltaire, Stern Iron Maiden christ that list goes on and on.

Other times you find it. That pin that takes you back to when you fell in love and why you play.

2 more grails to go for me. TOM and Williams Defender

Overall Pins have become much like a BOAT for me. Break Out Another Thousand. Maybe it's worse.

Wake up

Try not to get Pinned Out.

In the morning, if my face is a little puffy I’ll put on an ice pack while doing stomach crunches. I can do 1000 now. After I remove the ice pack I use a deep pore cleanser lotion. In the shower I use a water activated gel cleanser, then a honey almond body scrub, and on the face an exfoliating gel scrub. Then I apply an herb-mint facial mask which I leave on for 10 minutes while I prepare the rest of my routine. I always use an after shave lotion with little or no alcohol, because alcohol dries your face out and makes you look older. Then moisturizer, then an anti-aging eye balm followed by a final moisturizing protective lotion.

And when Alexander saw the breadth of his domain, he wept for there were no more worlds to conquer.

------Hans Gruber

I now have this exact problem so I guess pursue the next Grail pin!

Sell them and start all over!

Okay, now I'm jealous.

LTG : )

Oh my God, it even has a watermark.