If you like Fish Tales, I'd get that. I've owned it longer then any other machine and it's still my guilty pleasure game. I don't currently own one, but if I didn't have easy access to one it would for sure be back in my collection. The other games I'm currently considering adding are AFMr CE, LOTR, or Iron Maiden.
Quoted from MRG:F-14 is the best bang for the buck in Pinball
Please consider it a friendly thumbs down. I just have F-14 rated as one of the most overrated games. One of only two games I've owned that I was happy to leave my collection. Hardbody lasted years longer then F14 for me.