I know the barcade 1up in Denver had a nice mix. I loved Family Guy, TSPP was popular although not my favorite, TAF is a money making fool and was always busy. Doctor Who was popular as was Star Trek and LOTR. South Park as well. I was fairly new to playing pins and I gravitated towards subject matter I could relate to and understand.
As far as older pins I can not help there as they did not carry a bunch of older ones.